Creative Commons License
This work by www.tvsmarter.com is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 United States License.    





Kids Playing


(especially unstructured play)


versus


Kids Inside Watching TV,


Which is Better?






Advantages of Play


"Taking Play Seriously" - The New York Times (Feb 2008)


"Research Says" - What Kids Need (June 2002)


"The Serious Need for Play - Free, imaginative play is crucial for normal social, emotional and cognitive development. It makes us better adjusted, smarter and less stressed" - Scientific American (Jan 2009)


The Book "Play: How It Shapes the Brain, Opens the Imagination, and Invigorates the Soul" by  Stuart Brown - Amazon and U.S. News and The New York Times Blog


"Play's the Thing, a new book argues that play may be the primary means nature has found to develop our brains." - The Atlantic (May 2010)


"Parents and educators who favor traditional classroom-style learning over free, unstructured playtime in preschool and kindergarten may actually be stunting a child’s development instead of enhancing it, according to a University of Illinois professor who studies childhood learning and literacy development." - Science Daily (Feb 2009)


"Forget all the media products for babies on the market and go for the classic building blocks, suggests a new study linking playing with blocks with improved language acquisition in toddlers." - The Vancouver Sun (Nov 2006)


"In an article published in the April issue of Current Directions in Psychological Science, Sergio and Vivian Pellis of the University of Lethbridge reviewed multiple studies involving animals, and found a link between rough and tumble play and social competence." - Science Daily (March 2007)


"He and his colleagues exposed half of a group of rats to a traumatic experience (half were controls). They then enabled half the rats to play and interact with other rats, as opposed to being in their normal cages. The results were staggering; Rats who were able to interact with other rats (make "rat friends") for 9 days had less stress when again exposed to the traumatic experience 3 weeks later." - Psychology Today Blog (Dec 2009)


"Why would a behavior develop across multiple species if it doesn't have some ulterior function? The most common theory is that juveniles play at the skills they will need as adults. But some newer thinking proposes it's more than that. In fact, play seems to have some immediate perks, such as aerobic conditioning, as well as long-term benefits that include preparing animals for the unexpected and giving them a sense of morality... Human children learn similar lessons in their play as they interact with peers and learn which behaviors gain them friends and social status and which do not, say researchers." - American Psychological Association (March 2002)


"Encouraging children to entertain themselves in mentally active and imaginative ways and to avoid passive, quick-fix entertainment could also reduce boredom. “We provide children lots of entertainment in the form of television and iPods to prevent them from developing their inner skills to contend with boredom,” Sundberg says. Engaging in active entertainment, such as playing sports or games, is also much more likely to produce flow, Csikszentmihalyi says. Developing ways to cope with boredom may even help cure other ills. For example, some research hints that if former drug addicts learn to deal effectively with boredom, they are less likely to relapse. In an ongoing study of 156 addicts at a methadone clinic at Beth Israel Medical Center in New York City, Todman found that the addicts’ reported level of boredom was the only reliable indicator of whether they would stay clean." - Scientific American (Dec 2007)


"Playtime Is Over"  -  The New York Times (March 2010)


"Can PLAY Diminish ADHD and Facilitate the Construction of the Social Brain?" - PubMed (May 2007)


Part 1 of 3  "Development experts say children suffer due to lack of unstructured fun" - Post-Gazette (Oct 2002)


Part 2 of 3  "Creative play makes better  problem-solvers" - Post-Gazette (Oct 2002)


Part 3 of 3  "Experts call unstructured play essential to children's growth" - Post-Gazette (Oct 2002)


Young Children Need to Play!


Self-Regulation, Creative Play, and Television via Unplug Your Kids  more at  tvSmarter blog   Fairies and Philosophy


"Recently, I've had to change my mind about the very nature of knowledge because of an obvious, but extremely weird fact about children - they pretend all the time. Walk into any preschool and you'll be surrounded by small princesses and superheroes in overalls - three-year-olds literally spend more waking hours in imaginary worlds than in the real one. Why? Learning about the real world has obvious evolutionary advantages and kids do it better than anyone else. But why spend so much time thinking about wildly, flagrantly unreal worlds? " - Edge (2008)


Preschoolers do better when they talk to themselves


The Varieties of Play Match the Requirements of Human Existence - Psychology Today Blog (Oct 2008)


"Children Educate Themselves III: The Wisdom of Hunter-Gatherers" - Psychology Today Blog (August 2008)


"Have you ever stopped to think about how much children learn in their first few years of life, before they start school, before anyone tries in any systematic way to teach them anything? Their learning comes naturally; it results from their instincts to play, explore, and observe others around them." - Psychology Today Blog (July 2008)


Why We Should Stop Segregating Children by Age: Part III—Older Children Are Excellent Models, Helpers, and Teachers - Psychology Today Blog (Sept 2008)


"How Play Promotes Reasoning in Children and Adults" -  Psychology Today Blog (Dec 2008)


"Of Robotic Vacuum Cleaners and Free Range Children"  -  Psychology Today Blog (April 2010)


"From landscape to playscape" -  San Francisco Chronicle (July 2009)


Self-Regulation, Creative Play, and Television via Unplug Your Kids  more at  tvSmarter blog   Fairies and Philosophy


"The Changing Nature of Play: Implications for Pediatric Spinal Cord Injury" - PubMed (Jan 2007)





Kids Not Playing


"American children aged 2-11 are watching more and more television than they have in years. New findings from The Nielsen Company show kids aged 2-5 now spend more than 32 hours a week on average in front of a TV screen. The older segment of that group (ages 6-11) spend a little less time, about 28 hours per week watching TV, due in part that they are more likely to be attending school for longer hours." - Neilsen Wire (Oct 2009)


"Young people spend an average of three hours a day watching TV, and close to four hours a day (3:51) when videos and prerecorded shows are included. TV-watching time is highest among younger kids: 8-to 10-year-olds spend more than four hours a day (4:10), including videos and recorded shows. (page 26)" - Kaiser Study (2005)


"While most teenagers (60 percent) spend on average 20 hours per week in front of television and computer screens, a third spend closer to 40 hours per week, and about 7 percent are exposed to more than 50 hours of 'screen-time' per week, according to a study presented at the American Heart Association's 48th Annual Conference on Cardiovascular Disease Epidemiology and Prevention." - Science Daily (March 2008)


"A poll of 2,100 children conducted by the Telegraph has found that half of eight to 14-year-olds watch a minimum of four hours of television a day during term time.  Even more time is spent in front of the television at weekends and holidays, with some children more than doubling their daily viewing."  - The Telegraph (July 2004)




"Development experts say children suffer due to lack of unstructured fun" - Post-Gazette (Oct 2002)


"Now an alarming new survey from the Children's Society and the Children's Play Council reveals just how unhealthy the next generation has become.  The poll of 670 children, which was released yesterday, shows 40 per cent don't go out as much as they would like and 20 per cent admit they spend less than an hour a week outdoors." - Mirror UK News (March 2005)


"Getting Lost in the Great Indoors. Many Adults Worry Nature Is Disappearing From Children's Lives" - The Washington Post (June 2007)


"Neighborhoods are like ghost towns, kids don't play outside" - Daily 49er (Sept 2006)


"...exercising regularly and staying thin will reduce lifetime CAD incidence and death. Thus, if you are highly oriented towards protecting your child from fatal accidents, say by encouraging them to stay indoors, this could actually reduce their safety and life expectancy over the course of their lives." - Psychology Today Blog (Nov 2009)


"Why Day Care Kids Don’t Play Outside" - The New York Times Blog (May 2008)


"Mom lets 9-year-old take subway home alone. Columnist stirs controversy with experiment in childhood independence" - MSNBC (April 2008)


"Of course, some children are pushed to anxiety through too many résumé-boosting activities. The problem is when this tiny sliver of American children sets the cultural narrative, chipping away at support for additional study time and the after-school activities that less-privileged children need. Already, districts facing budget crises are putting sports and after-school programs on the chopping block. It's like college health centers fretting over anorexia when the greater risk for most students is obesity. In a world in which only 23% of ACT-takers show scores that indicate "college readiness" in math, English, reading and science, and when studies peg the average teen television time somewhere between 15 and 24 hours a week, most children are not at risk of being overscheduled." - The Wall Street Journal (Sept 2009)






Natural Environment


"The numbers coincide with national polls indicating that children and teenagers play outdoors less than young people did in the past. Between 1997 and 2003, the proportion of children ages 9 to 12 who spent time hiking, walking, fishing, playing on the beach or gardening declined 50 percent, according to a University of Maryland study."


"In a typical week, only 6 percent of children ages nine to thirteen play outside on their own. Studies by the National Sporting Goods Association and by American Sports Data, a research firm, show a dramatic decline in the past decade in such outdoor activities as swimming and fishing. Even bike riding is down 31 percent since 1995." - Alternet


Childhood pastimes are increasingly moving indoors - Free Range Kids versus Battery Cage kids


Nature Conservancy President Steve McCormick said the study suggests Americans and their children in particular are losing their connection to the natural world.


Pergams and another researcher set out to determine why visitation to national parks dropped 25 percent between 1987 and 2003.


Last Child in the Woods: Saving Our Children from Nature-Deficit Disorder (2006)







Daydreaming


"Study confirms robust daydreaming and superior intelligence are connected." - Psycholodgy Today Blog (Jan 2010)


"Study confirms robust daydreaming and superior intelligence are connected." - The Frontal Cortex (Sept 2008)








Play Therapy


"ESDM was designed to address the needs of toddlers with autism as young as 12 months old, and it is delivered by trained therapists and their parents in a very natural setting -- the child's own home -- with children sitting on the floor and playing, rather than having a more adult-directed therapy. "It's a very pleasing kind of therapy, kids are happy. It is play, and it can happen everywhere," Rogers explains. Dawson adds that this type of intervention builds on a fun, positive relationship with the therapist." - CNN (Nov 2009)








Essays on Play


"How to let kids be kids" - Seattle PI (Sept 2009)


"Nurturing Imagination" - The Informed Parent


"Why Creative Play Matters" - Education.com


"Kids Have Fun Thinking Inside the Box" - CCFC


"Play, Empathy and TV" - handinhandparenting.org


"A Play Challenge" - One in 36 Million


"Role-playing games pull reluctant school kids into a supportive crowd" - The Christian Science Monitor





 TV Makes Play Boring


"This ownership phenomenon is well-known to adults who read a book, and then go see a movie based on the book. The movie never lives up to our expectations because our imaginations have engaged the story, wrestled and played with it, and made it our own .Children who become addicted to TV gradually lose their ability to engross themselves in self-directed, creative play. They become easily bored.The arousal effect of TVs rapid movement and boisterous color and sound produces restless and aggressive behav ior among children, and makes it more difficult for non-video activities to engage their interest. Their ability to concentrate on tasks is impaired. Their ability to grow and develop in school and in the home is retarded." - The New Citizen (Fall 1992)




Yes to Recess


"Forget Goofing Around: Recess Has a New Boss" - The New York Times (March 2010)


"More than 80 percent of elementary-school principals believe that recess has a positive impact on academic achievement, according to a new Gallup survey released Thursday. The support for recess comes even though testing pressures have led to cutbacks in the amount of playtime in US schools." - The Christian Science Monitor (Feb 2010)


"Play, Then Eat: Shift May Bring Gains at School" - The New York Times (Jan 2010)


"The 3 R’s? A Fourth Is Crucial, Too: Recess" - The New York Times (Feb 2009)


"School Recess Improves Behavior" - The New York Times (Jan 2009)


"Experts: Recess improves student behavior" - USA Today (Jan 2009)


"Research shows that play and recess support learning" - Museum of Play





No to Recess



"What About Play? When "screen time" and drills replace open-ended play, kids lose out" - Rethinking Schools (Spring 2005)


"Why Day Care Kids Don’t Play Outside" - The New York Times Blog (May 2008)


"An estimated 40 percent of elementary schools have eliminated or cut back recess, according to the American Association for the Child's Right to Play. In Atlanta, recess has been abandoned altogether and new schools are built without playgrounds." - AZCentral.com (May 2005)






Play Resources


Amazon Listmania List of Books on: The Power of Play


"Freedom to Learn" - Psychology Today Blog


"Let Your Kids Go Outside and Play" - Playborhood Blog


"Giving our kids the freedom we had without going nuts with worry" - Free-Range Kids


"Play Category" - tvSmarter Blog 


"The Children & Nature Network (C&NN) was created to encourage and support the people and organizations working worldwide to reconnect children with nature. C&NN provides access to the latest news and research in the field and a peer-to-peer network of researchers and individuals, educators and organizations dedicated to children's health and well-being." - ChildrenAndNature.org


"Take your kids outside and skim stones, count butterflies or go fishing." - Leave No Child Inside 


"Discovery Time is a hands-on activity-based programme that puts students in control of their own learning" - Discovery Time 


"It all started with one woman hanging out flyers in the winter of 2006. She just wanted her daughter to have other kids to play with like she did when she was a kid, outside in all kinds of weather." - Activekidsclub.com









Non-Profits Promoting Play



Boys and Girls Clubs of America "Boys & Girls Clubs are a safe place to learn and grow – all while having fun. They are truly The Positive Place For Kids."


Kaboom "THE KaBOOM! VISION A great place to play within walking distance of every child in America."


Play England "Play England aims for all children and young people in England to have regular access and opportunity for free, inclusive, local play provision and play space."


American Association for the Child's Right to Play "The U.S.A. Affiliate of the International Play Association: Promoting the Child's Right to Play."


Strong National Museum of Play "Strong is the only museum in the world devoted to PLAY!"


The National Institute For Play "The National Institute for Play unlocks the human potential through play in all stages of life using science to discover all that play has to teach us about transforming our world."


The American Journal of Play "A new interdisciplinary journal dedicated to the study of play."


The Alliance for Childhood "The Alliance for Childhood promotes policies and practices that support children’s healthy development, love of learning, and joy in living."







Non-Profits Promoting Educational TV



C-Span.org "Created by Cable, offered as a public Service" (U.S.A.)


PBS "With your support, PBS programs and education services enrich the lives of all Americans." (U.S.A.) Note: Study Finds Lack of Balance, Diversity, Public at PBS NewsHour - Fair.org


PBS imported Teletubbies from the BBC last year and is aggressively marketing the program as educational for "children as young as one." - The American Prospect (May 1999)


Planet Read "Same Language Subtitling (SLS) is a simple yet powerful idea by which lyrics are added as subtitles to film songs on TV programs. Words are highlighted in perfect timing as they are sung. This association of the spoken and written word is a proven method to improve reading skills." (India) Article about Planet Read


Sesame Workshop "Sesame Workshop is a nonprofit organization of writers, artists, researchers, and educators. Best known for Sesame Street, we create educational content for children from birth through age 12, delivered through a variety of media including television, radio, the Internet, film, home video, books, magazines, and community outreach." (International) Note: Experts Rip 'Sesame' TV Aimed at Tiniest Tots


Smart Television Alliance "TiVo is proud to support the Smart Television Alliance."





Selected Play Quotes 


       from the Strong National Museum of Play



Play energizes us and enlivens us. It eases our burdens. It renews our natural sense of optimism and opens us up to new possibilities.

- Stuart Brown, M.D. Contemporary American psychiatrist


It is a happy talent to know how to play.

- Ralph Waldo Emerson, American writer 1803-1882


Life must be lived as play.

- Plato, Greek philosopher 427-347 BCE


Play is our brain's favorite way of learning.

- Diane Ackerman, Contemporary American author


Almost all creativity involves purposeful play.

- Abraham Maslow, American psychologist 1908-1970


Whoever wants to understand much must play much.

- Gottfried Benn, German physician 1886-1956


A child loves his play, not because it’s easy, but because it’s hard.

- Benjamin Spock, American pediatrician 1903-1998


Play fosters belonging and encourages cooperation.

- Stuart Brown, M.D. Contemporary American psychiatrist


Children need the freedom and time to play. Play is not a luxury. Play is a necessity.

- Kay Redfield Jamison

Contemporary American professor of psychiatry


Do not…keep children to their studies by compulsion but by play.

- Plato, Greek philosopher 427-347 BCE



Children learn as they play. Most importantly, in play children learn how to learn.

- O. Fred Donaldson, Contemporary American martial arts master